There are two key scenes in Star One – both of which take place on the Liberator during the opening minutes. The first demonstrates Avon’s wish to end his association with Blake.
AVON: We can take Star One, let’s get on with it.
JENNA: Very stirring. When did you become a believer?
AVON: Are you just going to sit there? You have led them by the nose before.
BLAKE: Excuse me, are you going to answer her question?
AVON: Show me someone who believes in anything and I will show you a fool.
BLAKE: I meant what I said on Goth, Avon. We are not going to use Star One to rule the Federation, we are going to destroy it.
AVON: I never doubted that. I never doubted your fanaticism. As far as I am concerned you can destroy whatever you like. You can stir up a thousand revolutions, you can wade in blood up to your armpits. Oh, and you can lead the rabble to victory, whatever that might mean. Just so long as there is an end to it. When Star One is gone it is finished, Blake. And I want it finished. I want it over and done with. I want to be free.
CALLY: But you are free now, Avon.
AVON: I want to be free of him.
BLAKE: I never realised. You really do hate me, don’t you?
Blake agrees that Avon will take him back to Earth after the destruction of Star One and that the Liberator will then be Avon’s. This is a pointer towards the general direction that series three will take. With Blake absent it wouldn’t have been credible for Avon to simply inherit his crusading zeal, so we see a shift towards more SF stories and less battles with the Federation (the balance changes again in series four). Paul Darrow is excellent in this scene and it easily demonstrates that he’s more than capable of carrying the series.
Even more fascinating is the following exchange between Blake and Cally.
CALLY: Are we fanatics?
BLAKE: Does it matter?
CALLY: Many, many people will die without Star One.
BLAKE: I know.
CALLY: Are you sure that what we’re going to do is justified?
BLAKE: It has to be. Don’t you see, Cally? If we stop now then all we have done is senseless killing and destruction. Without purpose, without reason. We have to win. It’s the only way I can be sure that I was right.
This is such a key moment, as it shines a very cold and clear light on Blake and his convictions. Earlier in the episode Servalan is shown examples of what happens when Star One fails – droughts, storms, terrible devastation, etc. If Blake destroys Star One then these disasters will just be the tip of the iceberg. Can any cause possibly justify this loss of life? It’s hard to agree with Blake that it does – his sole motive for continuing is because he’s gone too far down the road of freedom fighter/terrorist (delete as applicable) to stop now. It seems a monumentally poor reason for such wholesale destruction.
As we’ll see, Blake doesn’t destroy Star One. Aliens have infiltrated the complex and the Liberator finds itself allied with a fleet of Federation ships in a desperate attempt to stop a massive alien invasion. It’s possible to argue that the unexpected appearance of aliens is something of a cop-out. The Federation in series three is shown to be in disarray following the battle with the aliens and had Blake destroyed Star One there would have been a similar amount of disruption.
Star One is manned by a small number of Federation personnel, most of whom have been replaced by the shape-shifting aliens. This makes no sense – we’re told nobody ever visits, so why didn’t the aliens simply kill everybody and then take over? It’s also not clear why Star One has been failing recently – were these problems caused by the aliens or was Star One starting to run down of its own accord?
It also seems that quite a few events have been happening off-screen – when did Travis decide to ally himself with the aliens and why should he now wish to destroy all humanity? He’s always been more than a little unstable, but this sudden desire to kill everybody doesn’t really sit with what we’ve previously seen.
With Gareth Thomas’ departure it was decided that Travis’ main function in the series was over. And it’s difficult not to raise a cheer as Avon finally kills him off and sends him spinning down a very deep hole (via some very unconvincing CSO). The problems with Travis during series two weren’t all down to Brian Croucher, but there’s no doubt that Travis’ death is a mercy killing (both for himself and the audience).
We end with a cliffhanger as Avon leads the Liberator in an apparently hopeless battle against the oncoming alien fleet. There’s one final moment between Blake and Avon (“Avon, for what it is worth, I have always trusted you, from the very beginning.”) and then the credits roll.
After some wobbles in the second half of the season (Hostage, Countdown, Voice from the Past, The Keeper) Star One manages to close the second run on a high. It’s a very talky episode, with little in the way of impressive visuals or effects (the alien fleet looks to be cobbled together from whatever was lying around the Special Effects workshop for example). But the dialogue heavy nature of the story isn’t a problem as it allows all the regulars a chance to shine.